US-China experts warn of ‘a bloody affair for both sides’ if war were to start

[ad_1]

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

Any conflict between the United States and China would prove costly for both sides and would be resolved based on a few key points — and not necessarily in America’s favor, defense experts tell Fox News Digital .

“If you had to rank them, I’d put Taiwan first, the South China Sea second, the Senkaku Islands third, and then anywhere else in the world,” said James Anderson, acting undersecretary of defense for policy. under the Trump administration, adding that the Sea of ​​Japan could also serve as a flashpoint for conflict with China.

President Biden in May reiterated this position when he told a reporter that defending Taiwan, even militarily, was “the commitment we made.”

Fox News Digital spoke with former defense officials and experts.

UN HUMAN RIGHTS COUNCIL WEIGHS ACCUSING CHINA OF ‘CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY’

President Biden meets with Chinese President Xi Jinping during a virtual summit from the Roosevelt Room of the White House in Washington, DC on November 15, 2021. Photo by MANDEL NGAN/AFP via Getty Images

Proximity to China would provide Beijing with a significant advantage, similar to how Russia gained momentum during its invasion of Ukraine once it shortened its supply lines to focus only on the territories. just beyond its western border in the Donbass region.

PUTIN XI TO MEET FACE TO FACE NEXT WEEK IN FIRST MEETING SINCE WAR IN UKRAINE

“The problem is that in the Indo-Pacific theatre, the closer you get to China, the more [China] can concentrate its military assets,” Anderson explained. “What particularly concerns the United States and its allies are ballistic missiles and the fact that China is probably ahead of us with hypersonic weapons”, which could allow China to strike aircraft carriers and other hard and fast surface vessels.

Even with this advantage, China faces a significant conflict which, according to Dr. John Lee, senior fellow at the Hudson Institute and former senior national security adviser to Australian Foreign Minister Julie Bishop, would be “a very bloody affair for both parties”.

Members of the Chinese navy stand on the deck of the escort task force Suzhou missile destroyer at a military port on May 18, 2022 in Zhoushan, China's Zhejiang province.

Members of the Chinese navy stand on the deck of the escort task force Suzhou missile destroyer at a military port on May 18, 2022 in Zhoushan, China’s Zhejiang province.
(VCG/VCG via Getty Images)

“For the past two decades, the United States and its allies have been very passive, allowing the People’s Liberation Army to achieve air and sea dominance in this theater,” Lee said. “However, [they] are now taking seriously the development of long-range strike capabilities, hypersonic strike capabilities, asymmetric capabilities…and the range of non-military measures that would include crippling economic and financial sanctions. »

“In short, the United States and its allies have many good and powerful options to ensure that the military and strategic balance is in their favor,” he added.

SENATE COMMITTEE TO MEET THIS WEEK ON TAIWAN BIPartisan Defense Bill

Anderson also touted the US military’s ability to counter missiles. However, this ability loses its impact when faced with “saturation attacks”, which are effectively aimed at covering a target with missiles and extending defensive efforts.

The United States therefore also focused on trying to strengthen Taiwan through the “porcupine strategy”, which would see nations supply the island nation with a large supply of anti-tank and anti-aircraft weapons to help to close the military superiority gap that China holds.

Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen (R) listens while inspecting reservists training at a military base in Taoyuan on March 12, 2022.

Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen (R) listens while inspecting reservists training at a military base in Taoyuan on March 12, 2022.
(Photo by SAM YEH/AFP via Getty Images)

China holds a manpower advantage over the United States, with an army of 2.8 million Chinese soldiers outclassing the United States alone, according to the Brookings Institution, but a naval and air combat operation would significantly limit this advantage.

“At this point, China has air and sea dominance over the Taiwan Strait but cannot successfully land troops in Taiwan,” Lee said. “If it manages to do that, China will see the military option as more attractive.”

PUTIN SAYS US AND WEST IS FAILING, CLAIMS FUTURE LIES IN ASIA

Matt McInnis of the Institute for the Study of War noted that China’s focus will largely dictate its coordination and deployment: Any attempt to secure islands in disputed seas and straits would likely stifle Chinese forces , leaving limited use for troop deployments.

“Depending on your objectives and what they’re aiming to achieve through naval and air forces, you would potentially have some utility for the Marines to hold certain small pieces of territory and certain small islands,” McInnis said, adding that Beijing would only carry out an invasion. once he felt reasonably confident, American forces could not deploy to the area quickly enough.

Taiwan is holding military exercises to show its ability to resist Chinese pressure to accept Beijing's political control over the island.

Taiwan is holding military exercises to show its ability to resist Chinese pressure to accept Beijing’s political control over the island.
(AP Photo/Johnson Lai)

Anderson noted that China has closed the gap in other military areas but has yet to overtake the United States, acknowledging that China has “the most number of ships in the world today,” but that the United States still has the advantage in terms of quality, and so does a “superior” US Air Force.

The United States can also count on regional partners. China, by contrast, has few allies to turn to, mostly turning to countries like Russia to help it “deflect” economic pressure from the United States and its allies, according to McInnis.

PENTAGON HALTS F-35 DELIVERIES AFTER DISCOVERING JET COMPONENTS FROM CHINA

“There will certainly be economic lines of effort… and I’m sure China is looking at the long term how Russia, as well as key energy suppliers like Iran, can help them manage the economic fallout from conflict with the United States,” he said. “But I don’t think we’re quite there in the relationship between countries, certainly including North Korea. , where they would necessarily provide operational support or lethal aid directly to China. »

Lee believes China’s position has weakened since it nodded and revealed ‘broader intentions’ to ‘dominate East Asia’, a move that has also encouraged the US and their allies to ensure they thwart China’s ambitions.

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP

“China is trying to win by convincing the United States and its allies that it is not worth defending Taiwan, that the cost would be too high,” he said. “China’s problem is that it has revealed its larger intentions, which are to dominate East Asia. Therefore, a successful Chinese takeover of Taiwan would encourage China to push further rather than lead to more contented power.”

[ad_2]
Fox Gt

Not all news on the site expresses the point of view of the site, but we transmit this news automatically and translate it through programmatic technology on the site and not from a human editor.
Back to top button